Skip to main content

Permissions

Add user
Done

Start your AI search

AI search
Outbound call compliance Gamification for customer service Outsourcing services

How to write an RFP for consumer identity

Requirements, questions, and evaluation criteria specific to consumer identity procurement

7 min read

Consumer Identity and Access Management (CIAM) solutions are critical for organizations that interact with customers online. Procuring the right CIAM platform requires a detailed RFP to ensure the solution meets specific security, scalability, and user experience needs, while also adhering to evolving privacy regulations.

What makes consumer identity RFPs different

RFPs for CIAM solutions are unique due to the blend of security, user experience, and compliance requirements. Unlike workforce identity management, CIAM focuses on external users, requiring a different approach to authentication, authorization, and data privacy. The need to balance robust security measures with a seamless customer journey adds complexity.

Furthermore, organizations must consider the evolving landscape of privacy regulations like GDPR and CCPA, which impose strict requirements on consent management and data handling.

  • Scalability to handle millions of users and unpredictable traffic spikes
  • Support for diverse authentication methods, including passwordless options and multi-factor authentication (MFA)
  • Integration with various marketing, CRM, and analytics platforms
  • Compliance with relevant data privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR, CCPA, HIPAA)

RFP vs RFI vs RFQ

Here's when to use each document type when procuring consumer identity software.

RFI

Request for Information

Use early in your search to understand what vendors offer and narrow your list. Gather general capabilities, company background, and high-level pricing ranges.

RFP

Request for Proposal

Use when you know your requirements and want detailed vendor solutions and pricing. This is your main evaluation document for shortlisted vendors.

RFQ

Request for Quote

Use when requirements are fixed and you just need final pricing. Often used after RFP when you're ready to negotiate with finalists.

For Consumer Identity, an RFI is useful for initial research to understand available features and vendor landscape. An RFP is necessary for a detailed evaluation of technical capabilities, security measures, and compliance adherence. An RFQ is less suitable due to the complexity of CIAM solutions and the need for tailored configurations.

Technical requirements checklist

Use this checklist when defining your RFP scope.

Authentication Methods

  • Password-based authentication
  • Multi-factor authentication (MFA) with various options (SMS, email, authenticator apps, biometrics)
  • Passwordless authentication (FIDO2, WebAuthn, magic links)
  • Social login (Google, Facebook, etc.)
  • Adaptive authentication based on risk factors

User Management

  • Self-service registration and profile management
  • Account recovery and password reset
  • Consent management and preference tracking
  • Progressive profiling to collect data over time
  • Account linking and merging

Integration Capabilities

  • CRM integration (Salesforce, HubSpot, etc.)
  • Marketing automation platform integration
  • API-first architecture for custom integrations
  • SDKs for web and mobile applications
  • Integration with analytics platforms

Security and Compliance

  • Data encryption at rest and in transit
  • Compliance with GDPR, CCPA, and other relevant regulations
  • Fraud detection and bot mitigation
  • Vulnerability management and penetration testing
  • Data residency options

Scalability and Performance

  • Support for millions of users
  • High availability and disaster recovery
  • Low latency authentication
  • Ability to handle traffic spikes
  • Global infrastructure and CDN support

Questions to include in your RFP

Architecture & Deployment

  • Describe your platform's architecture, including data storage and processing locations.
    Understanding the architecture helps assess scalability and data residency compliance.
  • What deployment options are available (cloud, on-premise, hybrid)?
    Different deployment models offer varying levels of control and flexibility.
  • How does your solution ensure high availability and disaster recovery?
    Ensures business continuity in case of outages or disasters.
  • Detail your approach to data isolation and multi-tenancy.
    Critical for data security and preventing cross-customer data breaches.

Authentication & Security

  • What multi-factor authentication (MFA) methods are supported?
    MFA is essential for preventing account takeovers.
  • Describe your passwordless authentication capabilities (e.g., FIDO2, WebAuthn).
    Passwordless authentication enhances security and improves user experience.
  • How does your system detect and prevent fraudulent activities, such as bot attacks and account takeovers?
    Protecting against fraud is a crucial aspect of CIAM.
  • What is your approach to adaptive authentication and risk-based access control?
    Adaptive authentication dynamically adjusts security measures based on risk.
  • Detail your platform's vulnerability management and penetration testing processes.
    Demonstrates a commitment to proactive security measures.

Integration & Customization

  • What pre-built integrations are available with CRM, marketing automation, and other relevant platforms?
    Streamlines data flow and reduces integration costs.
  • Describe your API and SDK offerings for custom integrations.
    Enables flexibility and extensibility for unique business requirements.
  • How does your platform support identity orchestration and customizable authentication flows?
    Allows for tailoring the user experience and security measures to specific scenarios.
  • Explain how your solution handles data mapping and transformation during integration.
    Ensures data consistency and accuracy across systems.

Compliance & Data Privacy

  • How does your platform support GDPR, CCPA, and other relevant data privacy regulations?
    Ensures compliance with legal requirements and protects user data.
  • Describe your consent management capabilities and how you handle user preferences.
    Proper consent management is crucial for GDPR and CCPA compliance.
  • What data residency options are available to ensure data is stored in specific regions?
    Data residency is important for meeting regional compliance requirements.
  • What security certifications does your company hold (e.g., SOC 2, ISO 27001)?
    Validates the vendor's security practices and controls.

Pricing & Licensing

  • Describe your pricing model and licensing options.
    Understanding the pricing model is essential for budgeting and cost forecasting.
  • What are the costs associated with implementation, training, and ongoing support?
    Hidden costs can significantly impact the total cost of ownership.
  • How do you define Monthly Active Users (MAU) for billing purposes?
    Clarity on MAU definition prevents unexpected charges.
  • Are there any overage fees or penalties for exceeding usage limits?
    Understanding overage fees helps avoid unexpected costs during peak seasons.

Reporting & Analytics

  • What reporting and analytics capabilities are included in your platform?
    Provides insights into user behavior and security trends.
  • Can your platform provide reports on login success rates, drop-off rates, and MFA adoption?
    Key metrics for monitoring system performance and security.
  • Does your solution offer customizable dashboards and reporting options?
    Flexibility to tailor reports to specific business needs.
  • How does your platform integrate with third-party analytics tools?
    Enables deeper analysis and correlation with other data sources.

Compliance and security requirements

Depending on your industry, you may need to require proof of these certifications and standards.

GDPR

Required if processing personal data of eu citizens. If applicable, request documentation on GDPR compliance measures, data processing agreements, and data breach notification procedures.

CCPA

Required if processing personal data of california residents. If applicable, request documentation on CCPA compliance measures, including consumer rights and data deletion processes.

HIPAA

Required if handling protected health information (phi). If applicable, request a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) and documentation on HIPAA compliance measures.

PCI-DSS

Required if processing credit card data. If applicable, request a current PCI-DSS Attestation of Compliance (AOC) and documentation on security controls.

SOC 2 Type II

Required for organizations requiring independent assurance of security controls. If applicable, request a SOC 2 Type II report to assess the vendor's internal controls related to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy.

Evaluation criteria

Here is the suggested weighting for consumer identity RFPs.

Functionality Fit How well the solution meets the stated functional requirements.
25%
Security & Compliance The strength of security measures and adherence to relevant compliance standards.
20%
Integration Capabilities Ease and flexibility of integrating with existing systems.
15%
User Experience The ease of use and overall experience for end-users.
15%
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) Implementation, licensing, and ongoing maintenance costs.
15%
Vendor Stability & Roadmap The vendor's financial health and commitment to future development.
10%

Some weights were adjusted based on your priorities.

  • Increase if the organization has highly specific or unique requirements.
  • Increase if the organization operates in a highly regulated industry.
  • Increase if the organization has a complex IT landscape with many integrations.
  • Increase if user adoption and satisfaction are critical success factors.

Red flags to watch

  • Lack of transparency in pricing

    Hidden fees or complex pricing structures can significantly increase the total cost of ownership.

  • Inability to provide customer references in your industry

    Suggests limited experience with organizations similar to yours, raising concerns about their ability to meet your specific needs.

  • Vague responses regarding security measures

    Indicates a lack of focus on security or potential vulnerabilities in their platform.

  • Limited support for data residency requirements

    May indicate an inability to comply with regional data privacy regulations like GDPR.

  • Poor performance during demos

    Slow response times or frequent errors during demos suggest potential scalability issues.

Key metrics to request

Ask vendors to provide benchmarks from similar customers.

Average authentication latency

Impacts user experience and conversion rates.

Login success rate

Indicates the reliability and usability of the authentication process.

MFA adoption rate

Measures the effectiveness of security enhancements.

Password reset help desk ticket volume

Shows the effectiveness of self-service account management features.

Time to implement

Helps estimate the resources and time needed for deployment.